17 Unconventional Thanksgiving Main Dishes That Aren’t Turkey

Ah, Thanksgiving. It’s that special time of year again, filled with gratitude, family gatherings, and an inevitable food-induced slumber. Picture a lavish array of family favorites, some recipes handed down through generations, others newly introduced, all centered around the iconic turkey.

That succulent turkey, a mainstay in many American homes. However, what if you’re considering (or need) a break from the traditional turkey centerpiece? Given the rising costs due to inflation and ongoing avian flu concerns, exploring alternative dishes might be wise. Here are some ideas to ensure your Thanksgiving remains unforgettable for all the right reasons.

If a whole turkey threatens to stretch your budget too thin, think about cooking turkey parts instead. You might find turkey legs, wings, or breasts, and we’ve got great recipes for each!

Consider ditching the turkey entirely. Some of our most memorable Thanksgiving meals featured no turkey at all. Explore vegetarian options or different types of meat.

Explore our recipes below for more specific suggestions, and may your Thanksgiving be as delicious and heartwarming as you envision.

Munni Pramanik and Sara collaborated on compiling this list.

1. Roasted Turkey Breast with Roasted Garlic Gravy

If you’re only finding large turkeys, consider just the turkey breast instead of a smaller whole turkey. This simpler option (no brining or stuffing) is still a crowd-pleaser.

2. Pressure Cooker Turkey with Dijon Gravy

An Instant Pot can simplify your turkey preparation significantly. Just ensure the turkey parts—be it drumsticks or thighs—fit well in the cooker.

3. Traditional Beef Rouladen

According to contributor Devan Grimsrud, “In Germany, beef slices for rouladen are readily available at butcher shops. In the U.S., you’ll need to ask your butcher to thinly slice a round cut for you.”

4. Smothered Turkey Wings

Turkey wings, an underrated option, are perfect for a smaller gathering. They’re often available when whole turkeys are not, and you can find them fresh in the regular poultry section.

5. Glazed Baked Ham

Many families include both turkey and ham in their large holiday feasts. Hams are available in various sizes, which could be a great alternative if turkey stocks are low.

6. Dry Brined Roast Chicken

Contributor Karishma Pradhan recalls her first Thanksgiving, which featured a roast chicken to better fit her smaller family gathering.

7. How to Roast a Goose

Roasting a goose can create a Thanksgiving to remember! Hank Shaw, a seasoned hunter, also suggests this method for duck and offers tips for perfectly searing the breasts mid-roast.

8. Cheesy Artichoke Pie

For a show-stopping vegetarian centerpiece, try this stunning Cheesy Artichoke Pie. It’s straightforward to prepare and cooks in under two hours.

9. Vegan Stuffed Squash with Mushrooms

This year, we’re featuring Vegan Stuffed Squash at my home. It’s festive and pairs wonderfully with our Vegan Mushroom Gravy. Plus, you can prepare it entirely ahead of time!

10. Easy Baked Salmon

Don’t be fooled by the name; Easy Baked Salmon can be quite impressive. Serve it with a choice of tapenade, remoulade, or a lemon-garlic butter sauce instead of traditional gravy.

11. Roast Beef Tenderloin with Sautéed Mushrooms

Although more common at Christmas, why not preview the holiday with a succulent beef tenderloin? This dish serves four and is ready in just an hour. If you’re hosting more, consider a larger beef roast or a prime rib.

12. Pork Crown Roast

A crown roast of pork, essentially connected bone-in rib chops arranged for dramatic presentation, makes a fabulous alternative to turkey. It pairs beautifully with traditional Thanksgiving sides.

13. Roasted Chicken with Carrots

Everyone loves a well-prepared roasted chicken. This simple yet flavorful dish is ready in only 1 1/2 hours, making it ideal for a busy Thanksgiving.

14. Beef Brisket Pot Roast

Cooking a beef brisket pot roast for the family doesn’t have to be intimidating. This recipe can comfortably serve up to 12 guests and requires minimal attention during its 4-hour cook time, allowing you to enjoy your family’s company.

15. Cranberry Apple Stuffed Pork Loin

Embrace the flavors of fall with a cranberry and apple stuffed pork loin. The combination of tart cranberries and sweet apples complements the succulent pork for a festive and delicious main dish.

16. Garlic Herb Butter Prime Rib

Imagine a prime rib, perfectly roasted, with a fragrant garlic herb butter. It’s a show-stopping centerpiece that will draw your family to the table with its irresistible aroma and mouthwatering taste.

17. Roasted Cabbage Steaks with Garlic Breadcrumbs

For a quick and easy vegetarian option, try these roasted cabbage steaks topped with garlic breadcrumbs. This dish is versatile and can be prepared ahead, perfect for a stress-free Thanksgiving meal.