Yella Hewings-Martin, Ph.D
Vaccine efficacy is the percentage reduction in a disease in a group of people who received a vaccination in a clinical trial. It differs from vaccine effectiveness, which measures how well a vaccine works when given to people in the community outside of clinical trials.
All new vaccines undergo clinical trials to test how well they work. The developers of a vaccine candidate usually determine the main goals of their trial in their clinical trial study protocol.
These goals are called the primary endpoints. For many experimental COVID-19 vaccines currently in development, the primary endpoints focus on preventing new cases of symptomatic COVID-19.
Scientists can calculate how well a vaccine candidate works by looking at the difference in new cases of the disease between the group receiving a placebo and the group receiving the experimental vaccine.
This is called vaccine efficacy. For example, Pfizer/BioNTech reported an efficacy of 95 pecrent for the COVID-19 vaccine. This means a 95 percent reduction in new cases of the disease in the vaccine group compared with the placebo group.
Efficacy versus effectiveness
Volunteers taking part in vaccine clinical trials often undergo close monitoring. The trial team is usually aware of the participants’ general health and any relevant health conditions.
Participants usually report any side effects and may fill out daily symptom monitoring diaries.
Many clinical trials have exclusion criteria such as pregnancy, particular health conditions, and age. Trials involving experimental vaccines rarely include children or seniors until scientists have collected a significant amount of safety data to protect these groups from potential harm.
Vaccine efficacy only provides information about how well a vaccine works under the conditions of the clinical trial. Scientists usually base it on factors that they can quantify, such as numbers of laboratory-confirmed cases of COVID-19.
But the ideal conditions of a clinical trial do not necessarily reflect what is happening in the real world outside of clinical trials.
Vaccine effectiveness tells us how well a vaccine works under real-world conditions once people outside of clinical trials receive the vaccine.
Many factors can influence how a vaccine performs outside of clinical trials. One of these is the health of those receiving the vaccine. Underlying health conditions can affect vaccine effectiveness.
Another factor is how the disease-causing pathogen changes with time. The viruses that cause the flu are prone to mutations that make vaccines less effective. Vaccine developers update the flu shot every year to try to achieve a good match to the most prevailing seasonal flu strains.
Why are efficacy and effectiveness important?
Very few vaccines are 100 percent effective. But many routine vaccines have very high levels of effectiveness.
For example, the MMR vaccine is up to 97 percent effective against measles and 88 percent effective against mumps, and about 97 percent effective against rubella.
The annual flu shot has an effectiveness of 40–60 percent.
Some people may not develop full protection despite receiving a vaccine. Other people are unable to have certain vaccines. This may be because they have an allergy to components in the vaccine or because of other health matters, such as taking immunosuppressant medication.
While vaccine effectiveness can inform scientists how much it can reduce new cases in those who have the vaccine, scientists can also use this to work out how many people need to have the vaccine to reach herd immunity.
Herd immunity means enough people are protected from the disease to slow down or stop the pathogen’s spread. This means that people who have not had the vaccine or cannot have the vaccine receive indirect protection. – Medical News Today